Faces of a few young people against a backdrop of a complicated digital environment

Today’s Ofcom findings that TikTok and YouTube are “not safe enough” for children should concern anyone who works with, educates or cares for children and young people.

The regulator has said both platforms have not done enough to make their feeds safer for children, despite evidence that personalised recommendation systems are a major route through which young people encounter harmful content. Ofcom says neither company has made significant new commitments to reduce harmful content being served to children through these feeds.

This matters because the issue is not simply whether children “go online”, or even what they search for. It is how online environments are designed, governed and personalised around them.

Young people are not just choosing content. They are actively being served content by systems that recommend, amplify and repeat material based on attention, engagement and prediction – not primarily on age-appropriateness, wellbeing, or children’s best interests. That can include useful, creative and positive material, but also harmful content, misinformation, misogyny, hate, extremist narratives, scams and other risks.

These findings connect strongly with a current Home Office-funded project WISE KIDS is delivering across the six local authorities in North Wales. The project focuses on reducing young people’s vulnerability to online radicalisation, misinformation and related online harms.

We are currently in the final stages of our “listen and learn” phase, gathering insights from young people and practitioners. What we are hearing reinforces a key point: online risk is not only about individual choices. It is also shaped by feeds, peer dynamics, identity, belonging, humour, influence, and the way harmful content can be encountered gradually and normalised.

That is why platform accountability matters. Children should not have to carry the burden of managing risks created by powerful technology systems. Nor should educators and parents be expected to solve this alone.

But regulation alone is not enough.

We also need sustained education that builds children and young people’s knowledge, confidence, critical thinking, digital literacy, resilience and sense of agency. This includes helping them understand the human and digital factors that shape online risk: motivations, influence, identity, belonging, algorithms and recommendation feeds; how harmful content can be normalised or disguised; how to question, verify and respond to what they see; and how to seek help when something feels wrong.

Parents, carers and professionals also need support. Many are trying to guide children through digital spaces and technologies that change quickly and often invisibly.

The online environment is complex. That is why children and young people’s digital safety and wellbeing must be built into platform design, regulation, education and everyday conversations.