Photo of a mobile phone in a classroom

This week, the Government announced plans to move from guidance to a statutory requirement on mobile phone use in schools in England. In effect, this would make restrictions a legal expectation for schools.

Most schools already restrict phones, and this can support a calmer learning environment. But a more uniform approach in English schools risks missing some important points.

A ban addresses where phones are used — not how young people are engaging with the digital world.

From our work across schools, families and services, we know that in practice:

  • much of the risk sits outside school hours
  • online experiences are shaped by algorithms, influence and identity
  • issues like misinformation and online misogyny are complex and contextual

Restricting phones during the school day can reduce distraction. But it does not build the skills young people need to navigate the digital world.

That’s why restriction needs to be balanced with flexibility — using phones where they support learning, while giving young people opportunities to develop self-regulation and responsibility over time.

Why the Welsh approach is worth watching

The Welsh Government is taking a different route — developing guidance to help schools create policies that are appropriate for their context.

There is a strong case that this offers:

  • more flexibility and professional judgement
  • better alignment with wellbeing and inclusion
  • more space to combine restriction with education

There is also emerging evidence that phone bans alone don’t necessarily improve attainment or wellbeing outcomes.

Final thought

A focus on blanket restriction risks missing the bigger picture.
Our priority should be to genuinely prepare young people to navigate a digitally connected world.

They are digital citizens who need to understand it, question it, and engage with it in informed and thoughtful ways.

That’s where the real, long-term impact lies.

#DigitalLiteracy #DigitalCitizenship #MobilePhonePolicy #OnlineSafety #Education #EdTech